- Edited
Natch Congratulations, this is the best way to kill a community....
Yepp. What he said.
It's a pretty simple concept: People have ususally no interest to write stuff and to engage with other users if any of their posts could be deleted any time without any due process or explanation and if they could even be banned for simple writing something that doesn't please a creator. That's actually pure despotism.
That's why good communities have moderators enforcing known rules. Everything else is bullshit.
So the comment section will be basically worthless in the future, especially for those seeking honest feedback about a scene from other users.
There's few things more enraging than writing a long comment with honest feedback and finding out later that it was deleted without any explanation or warning. Paying subscribers should have the right to voice their opinion, good or bad. But with this system, it will be just another marketing scheme, not trustworthy at all.
Why even allowing comments in general? Just let the creators write a few glaring comments from fake users, it's pretty much the same result.