SLR Originals reset plan - Nov '23

petermc As for cookie cutter, he does basically the same boring vanilla scene every time with the same camera angles, same weird fetishes, same male talent. Just swaps the girls around, many of whom are pretty similar too.

No, he doesn't. Do you actually watch some of his scenes, especially his VRSpy scenes, or is this just some "I watched two scenes from him two years ago and now I just claim that every other scene of him was exactly the same" kind of argument? I do understand that you don't like his style and that's fine but stating that he did cookie cutter standard scenes is simply a ridiculous claim. If you blame him for doing that you must basically blame almost everybody else in the industry to do the same, only to a bigger extend - which is a pretty pointless statement to begin with.

Please show me directors from the sites you mentioned who feature intense girl-girl kissing, shared boy-girl pussy licking, footplay, creampie cleanups etc. on a regular basis. Well, to make it short, you can't. 95% of the stuff on the sites you mentioned consists of a small intro, some standard positions in a standard setting, cumshot, done.

VRplayful is good, never doubted that. But to bring up a studio with basically 3 scenes on the menu as the big example why Nash is so horrible is pretty hilarious. So Nash is bad because VRplayful is maybe even a bit better?

But yes, my statement that "we basically want SLR to be like VRSpy" was a bit over the top, was pretty obvious actually. I already mentioned that I want to have different directors on SLR as well. You know that I miss onthetelly, for example. But my statement wasn't more over the top or inappropriate than your "Nash is a terrible director". So before you lecture me on personal taste and everything else, take your own best advice. Like you told me, Nash isn't a terrible director just because you say so.

I believe I said “I think” he’s a terrible director. It was not stated as a fact but a subjective opinion. You saying, if I don’t like Alex Nash, I must like boring, standard, non-intimate cookie cutter porn is not. That’s you saying that only your own taste counts and people who disagree don’t know what they’re talking about.

I also never said his scenes are the same as everyone else’s. I said he repeats himself and makes the same stuff over and over. The same camera angles, same fetishes, same male talent, same vanilla sex and even a lot of similar looking girls. His scenes are cookie cutter as they have a formula and most look and feel the same.

VRPlayful were brought up to show that liking intimate porn and not liking Alex Nash are not mutually exclusive. I can appreciate intimate porn scenes and longer scenes when done in an exciting and interesting way. I’m not declaring them as the GOAT based on 3 scenes, that would be silly.

I will leave it there now though, it’s silly to be arguing over porn. None of it is Shakespeare is it?!! All it really boils down to is that you like his porn and, generally speaking, I don’t. We can agree to disagree.

petermc You saying, if I don’t like Alex Nash, I must like boring, standard, non-intimate cookie cutter porn is not.

Obviously you don't understand the meaning of a smiley and when somebody is just poking you with a stick...

petermc I also never said his scenes are the same as everyone else’s. I said he repeats himself and makes the same stuff over and over. The same camera angles, same fetishes, same male talent, same vanilla sex and even a lot of similar looking girls. His scenes are cookie cutter as they have a formula and most look and feel the same.

If that's true for Nash it's true for every single VR director out there, only to a bigger extend. Show me one porn director who doesn't repeat himself with basically every single scene. Yes, there's armpit action in almsot every one of his scenes but only on top of what everybody else is doing. It just adds to the menu. How's that worse than simply doing blowjob -cowgirl - reverse cowgirl - doggy - closeup mish, mish, cumshot - done like 99% of all VR scenes work? I don't get why you specifically blame Nash for being repetitive when his scenes include a lot more stuff than most others scenes out there. I asked before and I ask again: Which mainstream director e.g. adds footplay to quite a few of his scenes? I don't know any and I guess I watch more VR porn than you. And no, I don't accept VRPlayful again as an answer for everything, you already played that part.

I understand that you have reasons for not liking Nash like positions, angles, not enough anal, too much John Strong or whatever. Might be more than one reason, I actually don't care. But blaming him for repetition in an industry that is rifled with even much more repetiton is simply hilarious. That's like blaming France for having a boring cuisine when Great Britain is just a small leap across the pond...

Do actually watch for example his latest VRSpy scene with Melody Marks and then come back to this place. I do wonder if you'll still telling me to the face that all his porn looks and feels the same or is "formulaic" (beyond VR porn's formulaic nature itself) or even boring. Like what the heck?

petermc I will leave it there now though, it’s silly to be arguing over porn.

That's the whole point of this forum, lol. If arguing over porn is silly for you you definitely shouldn't have made an account in the first place...

petermc We can agree to disagree.

No, we can't, at least not on the statements you make. It's always easy to make bold statements and then act like it's all settled and dealt with. Well, it's not.

petermc said he repeats himself and makes the same stuff over and over. The same camera angles, same fetishes, same male talent, same vanilla sex and even a lot of similar looking girls. His scenes are cookie cutter as they have a formula and most look and feel the same.

correct. take VRSpy

Hazel Moore X 2
Madison Wilde X 2
Melody Marks X 2
Blake Blossom X 3
Layla Jenner X 2

No imagination unfortunately. Just formulaic. He regurgitates the same girls with slightly different faces and similar body types to appease a few drama queens who worship him. Imagine making your casting choices on the whims of 5 or 6 toxic characters who hardly ever have a positive word to say about SLR lol

His scenes remind me of the Badoink formula who cast similar women. However at least Badoink mix it up from time to time - Mandy Muse, Jessica Starling, Angie Faith, Emma Magnolia etc who ordinarily would be shot by Alex Mack for SLR. Nash wouldn't know what to do with these hotties.

justsomedude101 Ok it's updated. When I wrote this it was only showing 2 vanilla scenes. Raw Taboo is excellent.